WebIf the reviewer does not respond to the invitation, that is a strong indication that the reviewer is unavailable for review or is unwilling to review. ... The first option is to recommend acceptance without additional external review. This option is preferred for manuscripts which have in the opinion of the AE fully addressed the reviewers ... Web17 Feb 2024 · Peer review. Peer review is the process by which experts in the subject area review and article and provide their feedback. Journals typically have between 1-3 reviewers per article depending on the journal's review criteria and the availability of reviewers. Journals should establish how they will recruit peer reviewers.
How do I respond to an invitation to review in Editorial Manager?
Web22 Apr 2024 · A reviewer isn't obligated to preserve the feelings of the author, but there's no reason they should go out of their way to needlessly bash the author or their work, either. Feedback should be honest, thoughtful, constructive, and respectful. You hear that, Reviewer No. 2? Respectful, you butt face. Web20 Jan 2024 · Suggested reviewers can leave comments that are just as harsh—or just as supportive—as those from any other reviewer. In summary, if you were coming up with the ideal reviewer suggestion, it would be an active researcher with expertise in at least some aspect of your manuscript, with that relevant expertise explained. how much are heat pump systems
How to find peer reviewers - an editor
Web14 Aug 2014 · Preferred reviewers should not ideally be selected keeping only your paper’s acceptance in mind. Here are some pointers you should consider while selecting reviewers: Do not choose anyone whom you personally know so … Web3. Withdraw from the process, should you not have time to continue the review or should there be a conflict of interest 4. Recommend rejection to the handling editor should you find any objective errors in the manuscript To submit your independent review report, visit the review forum and fill out the relevant sections (see screenshot below). Web24 Jan 2024 · 1 Take reviewers’ comments as an opportunity even if your paper is rejected. 2 Check through reviewers’ comments carefully. 3 Be polite to reviewers’ comments. 4 Before you submit your response, make sure you address everything. 5 Be open to the reviewers. 6 Seek editor’s intervention in case you and reviewer do not agree on a specific ... photography west bromwich